Directed by: Will Gluck
Starring: Monica Barbaro, Callum Turner, Maya Hawke, Quintessa Swindell, Molly Ringwald, Levar Burton
One Night Only is a series of meet-cutes and misadventures of two fairly pleasant people who are destined to be together, but are kept apart over a twelve-hour period. This is no normal twelve-hour-period, however, but a twelve-hour-period once a year in which single people are permitted to have sex. Yes, you read that right. The hook of One Night Only is that a law was passed in which it is illegal for single people to have sex except for one night a year. My first question was: How do they enforce this? This is done through biometrics which are measured by small markings on the left wrists of single people. I suppose the goal is to have everyone be married and not have to put themselves through the annual ritual. How does Big Brother govern extramarital affairs? This is one of many questions which goes unanswered.
The main issue with One Night Only is that the one nagging question we have is: How did such a law get passed? There is a brief argument between two characters about the origins of the law, but to me that's the more intriguing prospect to explore. Everything else about New York City seems to be normal, but then the subways and streets are littered with postings about the twelve-hour exemption period and there is a red digital readout clock counting down from 7pm to 7am the following morning. People don't even find rooms. They just perform their PDAs right out on the street. There are some graffiti posts stating "Fuck the Mandate" and other meek protests, but it seems this law is here to stay. Oh, and you do have sex, you have to wear a condom. No ands, ifs, or buts.
Because One Night Only is billed as a romantic comedy, we have Allie (Barbaro), a singer of jingles about medications which cure psoriasis and other ailments which flood the media (not any different than the present day), and Owen (Turner), who owns a pizzeria. Owen has a girlfriend (Hawke), who confesses she wants to sleep with someone else on this night, so Owen is now single and heartbroken, but not immune to random hookups. Allie isn't exactly thrilled at the idea of sex with a stranger, but the movie wouldn't exist without prospects for her which include a musician she idolizes who turns out to be a creep, and another guy who turns out to be a parole violator.
Allie and Owen continue to run into each other and It Must Be Destiny, but other than these two are attractive and seemingly kind, there isn't much reason to care about either of them. They are two of many people looking for love in spite of this preposterous law. One Night Only is a typical romcom shrouded in High Concept, but maybe how the law came into being could be reserved for a prequel called One Night Only: The Beginning. Don't laugh or mock. It's not out of the realm of possibility. I'm reminded of the absurd Civil War (2024) from a few years back, in which Texas and California united and declared war on the rest of the country. The mandate in One Night Only is every bit as unlikely and laughable, even though the filmmakers are Trying to Make a Point that Conservatives Are Out to Get Us.