Directed by: John Curran
Starring: Robert DeNiro, Edward Norton, Milla Jovovich, Frances Conroy
Robert DeNiro and Edward Norton were electric together in The Score (2001), but while it's initially fun to see them together again in Stone, the movie itself starts strongly and ends as confused and directionless as DeNiro's Jack Mabry. Mabry is a parole officer on the verge of retirement when he meets Gerald "Stone" Creeson, who is itching to be paroled and tries any means (especially those which skirt protocol) to cajole Jack into writing a positive report for the parole board.
Stone sets up as a tense psychological thriller, but dissolves into nothingness. The opening scenes are promising, but don't develop into anything. We meet a young Jack, whose religious, overly subservient wife Madylyn serves him whiskey as he stares blankly at the television. When she threatens to leave him, Jack rushes upstairs and threatens to throw their newborn daughter out the window if she leaves. Madylyn relents and years later we see Jack driving to work and scenes of their loveless marriage. On the soundtrack is spiritual radio talk show chatter which sets the stage for some of the religious overtones the movie underlines.
Gerald is up for parole, and after an unsuccessful attempt to appeal to Jack's sympathetic nature (in which there really isn't one), then he sends his wife Lucetta (Jovovich) to seduce Jack. Jack finds himself willing to be seduced and then manipulated into writing a recommendation that Gerald receive parole. Gerald receives what he wants and Jack feels guilty about not doing right by his job. This is hardly a gripping cinematic experience although the movie and Gerald hint at something more sinister at play. Is Gerald enjoying bending Jack to his will? What is the payoff to all of this? The movie can't satisfactorily resolve the conflicts it starts, and in the end we're struggling to make sense of it all. Stone plays like a movie that felt a DeNiro and Norton reunion was enough to make itself palatable. These superb actors can only cover up so much.