Directed by: John Patton Ford
Starring: Glen Powell, Margaret Qualley, Bill Camp, Zach Woods, Topher Grace, Ed Harris, Nell Williams, Jessica Henwick
How to Make a Killing has the potential to lure us in and make us co-conspirators as Becket Redfellow (Powell) begins his quest to knock off the seven family members in line for his grandfather's inheritance in order to claim it for himself. But it never takes off. It plods when it should crackle. We should care enough to hope he either gets away with it or gets caught, but in this case, it's neither. Why is this? Because the characters Becket needs to bump off aren't established enough for us to root for their demise and Becket's plight isn't exactly one we can sympathize with.
Becket's mother got pregnant as a teenager and is subsequently cast out of her family by her father Whitelaw (oh, these names) (Harris) after refusing to have an abortion. Mom creates a life in North Jersey where she grooms her son to be a future inheritor of the family fortune. She dresses him in suits, teaches him how to speak like the manner-born, and eventually passes away from cancer while Becket is a teenager. Becket's dad dropped dead from an embolism while witnessing his birth, in case you were wondering.
After working as a tailor for a while, Becket decides to go after the fortune when his childhood crush Julia (Qualley) spurns him because she's marrying some rich prick. Julia acts like a femme fatale dropped in from a nearby thriller. She catches on early that Becket is up to no good and acts accordingly. The FBI also catches on since those who are dying are directly blocking Becket's succession to the inheritance. Becket has occasional pangs of conscience and also forms a relationship with Ruth (Henwick), the former girlfriend of one of the cousins Becket kills.
Becket tells the story to a priest while on death row awaiting execution. How Becket manages to avoid this is unconvincing and screams of an attempt to give this story a happier ending. Powell doesn't exhibit much charisma here, and we aren't much moved by his mission. He isn't sympathetic or even unsympathetic. He's just there. So is the movie and that's deadly.